Protectors of Privilege: When White People Call the Boys in Blue on Black People
Two black men waiting for a business partner at a local Starbucks in Philadelphia. Two black men working out at LA Fitness in Secaucus, New Jersey. A black female graduate student at Yale University power napping. Three black women leaving an Airbnb in Rialto, California. A black family setting up to barbecue in Oakland. A black child in San Francisco selling water to raise funds for Disneyland.
Each of these individuals made news headlines as the latest victims of white citizens who needlessly dialed 911. They were in different states, spending time in various spaces, yet faced the same situation.
Having the police called on you for simply living is nothing new to black people who live in the American social construct of race. But these latest incidents have confirmed they aren’t isolated. America does not have a “some people are racist” problem; America itself is a racist problem.
Why were the police called on these black people living out their normal, daily routines? Because a white person policed blackness to ensure the protection of their own privilege.
The conversation of white privilege may be at the point where it is falling on deaf ears but that doesn’t make it irrelevant. White privilege is alive and well and will continue to be if America does not begin to dissect it at its root. This country cannot simply repair the devastations of white privilege; it must repent of it.
White privilege has been constructed with bias, hatred, and systemic injustice. Generations before have lent their hands to the dirty deed of building it, and current generations simply have to participate in the system to protect and preserve it.
White privilege is protected by dictating the use of space and defining normality as “white is right.” You see examples of this in every one of these viral videos.
The Privilege of Power: Use of The Police
I have seen the potent power of privilege exhibited in the relational dynamics of white people and the police.
Looking at the facets of how police interact with black communities vs. white communities will make you believe the slogan to protect and serve primarily benefits white people while the back seats of police cars are meant for blacks. In 2014, The American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois completed a study on Equitable Policing in Predominately Black Vs. White Neighborhoods of Chicago. Here’s what they found:
“African American and Latino neighborhoods — largely on Chicago’s West and South sides — continue to suffer inequitable police services, according to new data obtained by the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois through Freedom of Information Act requests to the City. The data shows that as a result of a disparate system of deploying police officers across the city — over-deploying police in predominantly white neighborhoods — African American and Latino neighborhoods wait much longer for a police officer to be dispatched after an emergency 911 call, have fewer officers assigned to minority districts for each emergency call than predominantly white neighborhoods and that minority neighborhoods continue to have more violent crimes per officer than white neighborhoods.”
Statistics like these show that those who are truly vulnerable are not protected or served.
The Privilege of Space: Dictating Its Use
You will notice the above videos all shared a component: conflicted space. Black people had the police called on them because they hadn’t used the space in a way that assured white people of comfort. Or maybe it seemed strange that black people would be in white spaces at all.
Sarah Braasch, the white grad student that called the police on Lolade Siyonbola, is heard saying on video, “ I have every right to call the police. You cannot sleep in that room.” Sarah used her privilege to dictate how the space of this room was used. Even if not sleeping in a common room was a rule, students sleeping in public spaces on college campuses isn’t anything new. Moreover, I am sure there is a process to notify a residential assistant or a dean. Instead, Sarah used her societal power to summon the police to show Lolade Siyonbola that this space would be used in the way that Sarah desired.
The Privilege of Defining Normality: “White is Right.”
White privilege also carries the benefit of defining what is normal. Kelly Fyffe-Marshall, Donisha Prendergast, and Komi-Oluwa Olafimihan had the police called on them as they checked out of an Airbnb in California. Taking their luggage to their car didn’t seem like normal activity to one of the neighbors.
During this conversation, the neighbor states she saw “Strange people coming back and forth, you know, with luggage, and I didn’t recognize them.” The officer asked, “What made you think they were strange?” The women replied “ Um, because they had luggage in their hand, they weren’t really looking at me. You know they just kind of avoided me, or they didn’t wave, you know, like neighbors.” What didn’t seem normal to her? Was it that black people didn’t live in her definition of normal, so they must be up to something criminal?
The privilege of power, space, and defining normality belongs to God alone. Yet, when we act as if it belongs in the hands of an exclusive group, harmful and lopsided privilege arises. Until the privilege of power, space, and defining normality are understood as belonging to God alone, white people will continuously act as protectors of privilege, while blackness is continuously policed.
15 thoughts on “Protectors of Privilege: When White People Call the Boys in Blue on Black People”
Thanks, it is quite informative
Thanks, it’s quite informative
It works really well for me
I enjoy the article
Thank you for the wonderful article
Thanks, it’s very informative
Your pregunta seemed sarcastic, and if it was not then please excuse me, my apologies.
White privilege provides benefits that all people should have, but only to one demographic, one race (there are of course differences between white men and white women as well).
One good example is housing discrimination in most cities around the country. Many cities have a history of redlining which means keeping black people in certain parts of town and not granting them loans and insurances that would increase their mobility to move to another part of the city. These neighborhoods were not cared for and allowed by city governments to become more and more “undesirable”. In my city specifically in the first half of the 20th century if one black person lived in a certain area it could drop it from a rating of A to D (the lowest on the scale). Areas with a D rating were not given loans or insurances and deemed a “financial risk”. This created disparity and propagated segregation which has led to many issues black people continue to face today.
White people are privileged to have mobility and more freedom to choose where to live. To receive loans and insurances without worry of denial based on our skin color.
Like I said this is one example, and I hope I described it well (Others please feel free to alley-oop me on this).
Hopefully this helped, even if a bit divergent from the article. The hope is that people could just have barbecues, sleep in dorm study rooms, sell water to go to Disneyland, etc. and white people wouldn’t freak out from a sense of superiority/entitlement ergo privilege.
no respondiste mi pregunta
Dennis: What a stupid, pointless, and unhelpful comment.
It’s a shame how certain individuals continue to discredit the facts. Hence why we cannot and will not grow as a nation. Continuing to act as if certain situations were ok just because the outcome wasn’t violence towards black Americans is absurd.
If white privilege is so bad why is everybody else wanting to get in on it?
1. You’ll need the national guard for the south side of Chicago if you want to make a dent in the disparity.
2. We should be careful that single examples of people do not simply confirm our bias. You can find a Sarah Braasch just about anywhere and in various colors.
3. Be careful of mind/heart reading in assumptions. Sarah for instance could just be a jerk who wanted the space for herself. We don’t know how she treats others including her own color.
4. Positives in the BnB and Yale cases are that the police didn’t over react, but took the time to establish what the situation was, going as far as even to admonish Sarah in the Yale case for her abuse of calling the police.
5. Is it reasonable that we, if we saw anyone, regardless of color, removing lots of bags from our neighbors house who we didn’t recognize, that we’d make a call or at least stop to ask? How does one establish the basic motivation, when we know so little? Sure, it’s entirely possible the elderly white woman made a racist, white privileged response in the AirBnB case. But it’s also possible she was really attempting to guard her neighbor, and would have made the same decision had they been white.
6. Assuming hearts and minds can lead to irrational and poor judgment of others. As Christians we need to refrain from being quick to judge simply on appearance. Otherwise, we’re just as guilty as those we accuse.
We need to be very careful. The true church in Amedica is not racist. As a white man in a small town trying to get our police to take action on even small problems is near impossible. I’ve tried and they only do what they want. Even one of their own said they ought to fire the whole force including him. I really think many are mixing general sin issues and poverty issues with race issues. Of course oppression is a problem in a society like ours where most only pay lip service to the One True God who created all the races for his glory. But all genuine Christians are oppressed/persecuted also. But we’ve been told again and again to expect that and rejoice. It is better, if it is God’s will, to suffer for doing good than for doing evil.
That video about with the barbecue was the most embarrassing thing I’ve ever seen.
This is an amazing article!